Here’s a case of close, but no cigar with the stencil opening. The pads are, in fact, covered by the openings, but as you can see, the openings are too big.
This stencil would end up laying way too much paste down. Some of it would be on the solder mask which might bubble up and turn into solder balls. All in all, the use of this stencil might just lead to something of a gloppy mess.
When you’re making your paste layer in the library component (presumably, this was custom-made), it’s sometimes appropriate to make the paste opening the same size as the pad and it’s sometimes appropriate to make the opening smaller, but it’s never appropriate to make the opening bigger then the pad size.
After writing this, I for some reason got curious as to the origin of the phrase: “close, but no cigar.” I know it’s been around a long time, but I couldn’t come up with any plausible meaning for it. Then I remembered this thing called the Internet, so I looked it up. According to a couple of different sites, carnival booths, like the big hammer, would give out cigars as prizes so if you almost made it, the Carney, would say “close, but no cigar.” Huh. Interesting, but much less interesting then I had expected.
Sorry. We don’t give out cigars if your stencil is good.